A story of a summer affair in Second Life

Sordid Affair, Grace Island; Inara Pey, March 2016, on FlickrSordid Affair, Grace Island – click any image for full size

Sordid Affair,” Chuisle Alecto says of her homestead region (also known as Grace Island), “is the end of a summer’s love affair, as told through a photogenic beach sim capped with mountain forest. In Sordid Affair time stands still in heartbreak, for photography and to explore. Watch for clues and interpret the story your way.”

That may sound like a bleak description of the region, but while it might express a state of mind come the end of a relationship, it belies the simple, rugged beauty of the region; a beauty within which a story awaits discovery. One which, as Chuisle notes, the visitor is free to interpret.

Sordid Affair, Grace Island; Inara Pey, March 2016, on FlickrSordid Affair, Grace Island

The landing point, in the south-east corner of the region, forms a part of the low-lying beach which covers more than half the island as it sweeps around from the south, along the east coast and then curves back around to the north. Separated from this by a narrow ribbon of water and itself sitting on a rim of sand, lies a rocky plateau with steep, craggy flanks.

The beach is home to a little group of summer huts and, close by, but set apart from them by a fence, a small cottage and flat-topped hall. all of them are in turn watched over by the tall red tower of a lighthouse tucked into the north-east corner of the region.

Sordid Affair, Grace Island; Inara Pey, March 2016, on FlickrSordid Affair, Grace Island – click any image for full size

The plateau, reached by a single climb between rocky shoulders, is topped by woodland and grass which contrast strongly with the sands below. Amidst the trees can be found places to sit and a little pavilion, apparently awaiting guests for dinner. As one wander the island, other places to sit can be found scattered about, each of offering a hint of romance: places to snuggle and share. So, what then of story said to be waiting to be found?

This is actually to be found all around. The little snuggle spots form a part of it, as does the pavilion.  Further part of it can be found when exploring. What at first appears to be a small camp fire blazing through the trees turns out, on closer inspection, the be the funeral pyre of burning pictures. Down on the beach sits the concrete box of a war-time pillbox, wherein the reason the affair ended might be found. And then, across the beach, amidst the trees of the plateau and within the hall can be found several of Mistero Hifeng’s sculptures, each of which adds a further page to the unfolding story.

Sordid Affair, Grace Island; Inara Pey, March 2016, on FlickrSordid Affair, Grace Island – click any image for full size

This is a region which apparently changes in theme and design – and thus, I presume – story; as such, how long it will remain in its current form isn’t clear. So, if you do want to see how this particular story comes together for you, a visit sooner rather than later might be in order. For my part, I’m sure to be returning to Grace Island in the coming months to see what other treasures have been created there.

SLurl Details

Tony Dyson: robots, films and Second Life

Tony Dyson
Tony Dyson passed away at his home in Malta

Tony Dyson, the creator of R2-D2 and Emmy-nominated film SFx supervisor who worked on films such as Superman 2 and Moonraker, Dragon Slayer, Saturn 3 and The Empire Strikes Back, has passed away.

Professor, author, educator, and more, Tony Dyson was also keenly interested in Second Life.

He first became involved with the platform, as Azar Shelman, while investigating distance learning mediums, and recognised the Second Life’s potential as a means of creating real-time animation, something he had tried to do outside of the platform without much success.

As a result of getting involved in SL, he was introduced to  machinima producer and publisher Chantal Harvey,  (via Phalen Fairchild), and they found they had much in common. Chantal invited Tony to head the jury in the 2012 48 Hour Film Project for machinima, and thus a working collaboration between the two of them was born.

As well as investigating ways and means to produce better machinima, this collaboration led to the development of Bobbekins, interactive e-books for children which would utilised advanced animation, music, and machinima shot in Second Life, and illustrated by another SL resident, Dawny Daviau.

Bobbekins was developed on the idea that children expect to engage all their senses when involved in a story or learning exercise  – something to which educators can attest. Filming took place in Toy City, created by Tony as a constantly changing place discovered by the alien Bobbekins, who claimed it as their home. The books were developed under the Netdreamer Publications  banner authored by Tony, illustrated by Dawny and edited by Chantal, and the first book in the series, Medieval Farm, is still available through Amazon (and you can read more on the project here).


However, it is the builder of R2-D2 that he will be most clearly remembered. A regular guest at science-fiction conventions around the world, he never lost his love of the cylindrical little robot, and used the fame he gained through his involvement in star Wars to talk about creativity and learning and give ene[encouragement to young people to pursue their creative endeavours.

As well as building the original eight R2-D2 units, Tony Dyson was responsible for the design of Hector, the robotic antagonist in Saturn 3, and developed a robotic character modelled on (and voiced by) John  Cleese for a series of television adverts aired in the 1980s for Sony. He also designed robots for Philips and Toshiba.

Tony Dyson had a wonderful view on creativity “Be playful,” he told the The Times of Malta newspaper in 2015. “Never stop playing. If you look at life the way it really should be – enjoyed – then you become very creative”. It’s a view he shared with Shad Engkilterra at the Malta Comic Con in 2015.

Tony Dyson passed away at his home on the island of Gozo, Malta. My condolences to his family, and to Chantal and Dawny, and those who knew him.

Project Bento User Group update 7 with audio

Project Bento – extending the SL avatar skeleton
Project Bento – extending the SL avatar skeleton

The following notes and audio were taken from the weekly Bento User Group meeting, held on Thursday, March 3rd at 13:00 SLT on Aditi. For details on each meeting and the location, please refer to the Bento User Group wiki page.

Note that this update does not present the discussion in chronological order; items discussed have, wherever possible and without compromising the discussion itself, have been grouped together to try to present a complete discussion of the topics raised in turn.

New Project Viewer and Bento Skeleton

A new version of the Bento project viewer has been released. Version, dated March 2nd, 2016, includes the updated Bento skeleton, which the Lab hopes will be the final version.  In particular this adds further new bones:

  • Four new spine joints: two between mPelvis and mTorso, and two between mTorso and mChest. By default these bones are folded up inside the current spine and will not affect the appearance of the avatar, but like other bones they can be repositioned in uploaded meshes, or animated according to need
  • New face bone root: rather than adding extra neck bones, the Lab have added an extra face bone root, which could be used as an extra neck bone if desired
  • Three new centre face bones along the mid-line of the face, two on the lips and one on the forehead
  • Two new joints for ears, allowing for floppy or otherwise more flexible ears
  • An additional pair of limbs, each with 3 joints apiece, and a new root bone to which they are connected. These are named “Hind” limbs, but using the root bone, the can be relocated to be used elsewhere – such as an extra pair of arms
  • One new bone for each wing to allow a simple fan as would be used in a bat-type wing.
  • Removal of two wing root bones: these were originally included as a workaround for the lack of joint translations. As this is now possible, only a single wing root bone is actually required
  • Various bone position changes.

As some of the existing bones have been removed or changed position, this does mean that content made using the original Bento skeleton will need to be updated in order to display as intended. Aditi servers have been updated with the new skeleton.

Vir discusses the new bones and the removal of some bones

The ability to add new spine bones is a direct result of the Lab being able to fix the two issues referred to in my last Bento update, the first of which would crash the Bento viewer if additional spine joints were added, while the second was that new spine bones would break the rendering of the default avatar.

In order for this to work, the new bones have an odd positioning / ordering within the skeleton, so they seem to “zig-zag” (spine 1 is located in chest, spine 2 in the pelvis, then comes the torso, etc). The reason for this was to allow all the original skeleton joints exactly where they had always been located, and to avoid the creation of any zero length bones, with the internal matrix maths (as well as some other programmes) doesn’t particularly like, as Vir explained which discussing the new spine bones.

Vir expands on the new spine bones and ordering

There may be some issues which are causing Blender to incorrectly display the new spine bone positions and orientation. One suggestion for those encountering similar issues is to visualise the bones by setting them to the polyhedral models where it is wider on one end than the other (I’m unfamiliar with blender, so not sure of the precise term for the visualisation) to make it easier to see the orientation of the bones, although this may not work.

Aki Shichiroji, who has experienced the problems, has indicated she’d talk a little more with the Avastar team about things. Certainly, Vir believes working with them is going to require a delicate touch when working with the spine bones in the likes of Maya and Blender, due to the risk of coincident bones.

Next Steps

The Lab intends to freeze the skeleton soon, and those wishing to test it are advised to do so over the next few days. Currently, the easiest way to obtain the latest version of the skeleton is directly from the new version of the project viewer (link above), although hopefully the wiki links, etc., will be updated soon.

There is liable to be one more update to the project viewer once the skeleton is frozen, after which the Lab will be turning attention to the avatar.LAD file, the other major configuration file for the skeleton, and finalising changes and corrections to the shape sliders and potentially adding some new attachment points which can leverage the revised skeleton.

The biggest issue as far as progress the project to initial deployment on the main grid is concerned, is bug fixing. There are still some significant problems yet to be resolved, which are dependent upon understanding the route cause of the problem and having the staff available to investigate them / resolve them:

  • Issues with the extra joints, such as the default avatar pose issue (see below)
  • The rendering deformations encountered at high altitude
  • The general avatar deformation issue seen within the Bento viewer (see here and here for further notes).

There are also a number of more general bugs to be corrected as well.

Overview of the next steps in the project from the Lab’s perspective

Default Avatar Pose Issue

foreleg crossing: issue may be deeper than thought
foreleg crossing: issue may be deeper than thought

There has been further investigation into the default avatar pose issue which can see quadruped avatars unnaturally crossing or folding their forelegs when shifting between animations (for background see here, here, and here).

It had been thought that the issue was due to the way that scripted animation override systems (e.g. the ZHAO and ZHAO 2) overlay the default server-side avatar poses, occasionally allowing these server-side animation to start playing when shifting between poses as a result of a message timing issue between server and viewer. The suggested solution was therefore thought to be to encourage creators to write AO for their Bento avatars which would utilise the llSetAnimationOverride capability introduced in 2013, which overwrites the server-side defaults with the animations of the creator’s choosing, thus preventing the “wrong” animation starting to be played.

However, more recent testing suggests that the issue can still occur when using llSetAnimationOverride.

A problem here has been that the JIRA specifying the issue and providing information on various tests, etc., carried out to date by the Lab has, not been publicly viewable (for valid reasons), making it hard for other outside the Lab attempting to investigate the problem to understand what has happened to date and report their own findings back to the Lab. Arrangements are now being made to clone the JIRA and make is public to eliminate this problem.

Other Items

Removing Mesh Upload and Display Restrictions

Second Life has always had a number of upload and display restrictions wherein creators were required to include certain joint positions whether or not they were in fact using them (the uploader wouldn’t check to verify whether the positions were actually used, just that they are listed). There were some checks which insisted that if the positions of some of these bones were changed, they all had to be changed.

This obviously limited the number of meshes rigged to bones from different creators that an avatar could wear, because there would inevitably be conflicts between the listed joints in each mesh. The checks themselves date back to when the Lab used a different method for tracking joint positions, and they don’t make a lot of sense today, and so work is in hand to remove them, and should be completed with the next release of the project viewer.

The upshot of this is that once done and available, avatars will be able to wear meshes from different creators, providing the mesh items only list the joints they actually use. This would allow, for example, this will allow someone to wear a centaur avatar from one creator and add a set of wings from another creator without the risk that the meshes would conflict because they list the same “required” joint positions. However, for this to work, it does mean that creators will need to ensure they list only the joints they require in order to offer some degree of “interoperability” between meshes.

Vir discusses the removal of the upload and display restrictions

Using Bones to Animate Hair and Clothes

One benefit from being able to rig and list only the bones which are being used, is that it potentially opens the door to creators being about to use some of the additional bones to animate things like hair and dresses.

For example, as bipedal, humanoid avatars are unlikely to require the tail bones or the “hind” limb bones, these could potentially be used to naturally animate a  mesh gown (particularly one with a long train) or long dresses. Similarly, the additional ear bones might be used to animate mesh hair.

Cathy Foil points-out the potential for clothing and hair makers as a result of the removal of the restrictions

Scripted Methods for Bone Positions

BUG-11407 is a feature request to provide scripted control of bone positions, allowing to an LSL command to pass an array of bone positions to the client to animate oneself, or, with permission granted, to animate another user.

Commenting on this at the meeting, Vir indicated that while such an approach is “interesting”, but due to the scope of things, has been considered to big an undertaking for the Bento project, and would likely have to be considered as a project in its own right. Rider Linden further suggested raising the idea for discussion at the Simulator User Group meeting.

Useful Links