The third Sansar preview – and the second in a week – almost slipped by me, as I’ve been otherwise engaged in numerous things. And that would have been a shame had I missed it, as it offers a perspective on Sansar from none other than Maxwell Graf.
I’m bound to be biased here, as I’ve known Max for a long time – almost back as far as my earliest days in SL (he joined between my first and current stints in-world). However, he is worth listening to, because he knows his eggs. Max is behind one of the most well-respected content brands in SL: Rustica, he’s designed regions, work on Blue Mars and Cloud Party, has a finger on the pulse of High Fidelity and has been in Sansar from the initial phases of the current Creator Preview.
For this piece – running to one minute and 46 seconds, Max has a lot to say – and wisely, Drax lets him get on and say it uninterrupted. Of course, there are descriptions of the experiences Max has been building – one of which, unsurprisingly, is very Rustica. However, what is interesting is not what he’s building, but what he has been observing about Sansar.
One of the major critiques (from SL users) towards Sansar is the lack of contiguous space – even though, as I’ve pointed out, an experience can be four kilometres on a side (the equivalent of 16 SL regions on a side). That still may not be as big as a Mainland continent in Second Life, but Max puts it better perspective when it comes to something like period role-play (a popular pursuit in SL):
The really interesting thing about something that is on that scale is that from a role-play perspective, it does not have to be confined to a small village any more. You can exist on each side of the mountains and never even see each other because it takes three hours to walks across.
When couched like that, in an environment where flying could be disallowed, teleporting strictly controlled, etc., the span of role-play and role-play encounters could be far more involved than anything witnessed in Second Life – if and when Sansar has built up a mass of interested users. It also raises the potential for very real-time training and simulation uses for the platform.
Max also touches – admittedly lightly – on what is bound to be something of a struggle for balance on the part of Sansar content creators: pitching their goods and services at a price which reflects the effort put into creating / building them, and which users are willing to pay. In some respects, this is where Sansar could be initially hamstrung if its initial core user demographic is drawn from Second Life users, who will likely have certain expectations on the cost of goods and items because of their time in SL.
However, it is in his comments around Sansar’s potential for public reach which are perhaps the most interesting, coupled with the manner in which he is using Sansar:
What Sansar is going to offer the public is an opportunity to get an understand of what an open virtual platform really is about. And that’s going to make a difference, because from here on out, we’re going to be looking at the beginnings of what will become a true metaverse.
Just how likely this is going to be is open to question; will people really see VR and virtual spaces as important to their social engagement, for example. But the important element here is that Sansar’s potential success has been judged on the basis of its lean towards VR, and the fact that (thus far) VR hasn’t really grabbed what could be called a broad market; however; as Max demonstrates in this video is that Sansar can be practically used and enjoyed sans VR paraphernalia.
This is important because, like it or not broader-based user catchment and retention is going to be an issue for Sansar as much as it has been for Second Life, if for no other reason that many of the platform capabilities are going to take time to mature. If it is seen purely as being “all about the VR”, then that catchment is liable to be considerably narrowed, simply because people aren’t buying into VR in a big way as it stands right now (although as the hardware and costs improve, this could well change). Therefore, emphasising the wider potential for the platform to operate without all the expense of HMDs, etc., could boost the level of interest among “the public” (UI allowing). It’s just a pity this point is somewhat undermined by the (somewhat jarring) interjection of HMD use into Max’s narrative.
That said, this is still a further interesting video in a maturing series, and another step along the way to giving further insights into the platform as we move ever closer to Sansar’s public opening.
Inara Pey: Living in a Modemworld 
I do think it’s going to be a steep learning curve for those of us used to knocking up a build from basic prims in SL to adjust to Sansar, we’ll need to refine our vision and our own capabilities for using it.
We’ll have far more land available to use at a fraction – if not zero – of the costs in SL.
But we’ll have to temper this against the increased costs in buying content to use within Sansar. Swings and roundabouts
We’ll need to educate ourselves to use what is required to build well, rather than what is easy/ quick/ cheap for us to use.
We’ll need to consider our impact on the Sansar environment in much the same way as we’re now having to do in real life (albeit that in Sansar we may not be actually destroying something forever by our actions).
But for a very long time a lot of us have been ignorant of what constitutes ‘healthy content’ in SL. Our ignorance led by lack of education rather than a wish to make life hard for ourselves and those around us.
We have blamed everyone, and everything, for the issues we all sometimes have inworld.
Using massive textures, scripts and polygon heavy assets that bring our machine to a shuddering halt – fans whirring and black screens blinking.
Sansar is our new frontier – lets not mess it up this time eh.
LikeLike
You’ve nicely encapsulated some of what I’m hoping to say in a follow-on article – and in doing so have given me a nice lead-in to it, if I get it written! 🙂 .
LikeLike
I always like to be of help Inara 😉 ….and thank you for the compliment! xx
LikeLike
Wasn’t one of the early promises about Sansar was it would not have as steep a learning curve as SL? It seems to me that it will be steeper if you want to create but maybe simpler if all you want to do is experience someone’s experience.
Maxwell’s is the first Sansar video that has impressed me. It hasn’t made me want to even try Sansar when they actually do open the beta though. There will have to be some amazingly good feedback from actual users.
LikeLike
The fledgling nature is going to be problematic for Sansar and other early VR experiences. Oculus are having the summer of rift with a Rift and a touch controller bundled for £399.99, there are however rumours that a £200.00 wireless headset is in the pipeline for next year.
There are mixed reality headsets now being sold on pre-order to developers via Microsoft. These developments matter because VR headsets don’t yet have agreed standards and these developments can change the direction of the early VR offerings.
Sansar has potential, but people need to be patient, it’s very early days.
LikeLike
The wifi Oculus rumours (now seemingly confirmed) have been circulating for a while; it’ll be interesting to see what the actual specs are compared to the current hardware. HTC already has a 3rd party “tetherless” add-on wifi kit for their headset as well. In terms of MR systems – Microsoft has teamed with a number of hardware manufacturers, but the really interesting development appear to be coming out of Qualcomm via their Snapdragon 835 chipset (see: Enter the Snapdragon: Qualcomm and “XR”).
I’m still far from convinced that the Oculus and Vive moves will make VR any more appealing to a broader “mainstream” audience. Hence again why I’d suggest more emphasis on the non-VR capability of Sansar might be worthwhile (UI allowing). People can, after all, always get the hardware down the road, once they are more convinced of its potential use.
That said, I am convinced of Sansar’s potential within a number of VR-aware markets (as I’ve constantly banged on about in these pages 🙂 ), and am curious to see how LL pursue these markets, as they have been very conscious of them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Like you I would like to see more of what is the non-goggle capabilities of Sansar. Apparently that will have to wait until they actually open the beta. It too “sexy” to talk about having the cutting edge hardware.
Right now VR and AR hardware is too immature and expensive for a mainstream user. IMO LL needs to start talking about the non goggle capabilities of Sansar and also allow the non goggle users to have the freedom to make both good and bad comments about Sansar. If they don’t do that then Sansar may end up on the pile of ideas that had potential but failed because they were too ahead of their time.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on thomas mcgreevy.
LikeLike
If Sansar relies too much on VR, it is bound to fail. VR needs another decade.
LikeLiked by 1 person